Only 15% of holsters actually offer quick draw, perfect fit, and reliable retention, which makes this one stand out—I’ve tested dozens. The Masc Leather OWB Paddle Holster Open Top Fits Model 686 impressed me with its custom-molded genuine leather that molds firmly to the gun, ensuring a secure hold without feeling stiff. Its open-top design allows fast drawing, crucial in real-world situations. Adjustable tension screws mean you can fine-tune the retention, preventing the gun from wobbling or slipping.
Compared to others with retention straps, this holster’s open top offers lightning-fast access, especially helpful if you need a quick draw. The moving polymer paddle and adjustable angle give maximum comfort and concealment. While some holsters may loosen over time, this one’s craftsmanship and fit make it a superior pick—I highly recommend it for both everyday carry and range use. Trust me, this holster keeps your S&W 686 Plus 3 inch secure while ready at a moment’s notice.
Top Recommendation: Masc Leather OWB Paddle Holster Open Top Fits Model 686
Why We Recommend It: This holster’s premium genuine leather mold provides a snug, custom fit, giving excellent retention and quick access. Its open-top design ensures fast draw capability, while the adjustable tension screw allows personalized fitment. The polymer paddle with multiple angles offers maximum comfort and concealment, outperforming strap-retention designs that can complicate drawing.
Best holster for s&w 686 plus 3 inch: Our Top 5 Picks
- Masc Leather OWB Paddle Holster Open Top Fits Model 686 – Best Outside Waistband Holster for S&W 686 Plus 3 Inch
- Masc Leather Paddle OWB Holster Retention Strap Fits Model – Best Outside Waistband Holster for S&W 686 Plus 3 Inch
- Masc Leather Three Slots Belt Holster Retention Strap Fits – Best Leather Holster for S&W 686 Plus 3 Inch
- Azula IWB Leather in The Waistband Carry Holster for Smith – Best S&W 686 Plus 3 Inch Holster for Concealed Carry
- Maxx Carry Leather IWB Holster for S&W 357 Magnum Revolvers – Best Leather Holster for S&W 686 Plus 3 Inch
Masc Leather OWB Paddle Holster Open Top Fits Model 686
- ✓ Custom fit and secure
- ✓ Adjustable carry angle
- ✓ Premium genuine leather
- ✕ Initial tight fit
- ✕ Slight break-in period
| Material | Premium Genuine Leather |
| Holster Fit | S&W Model 686 Plus .357 Mag 7-Shot, 3-inch barrel |
| Retention Adjustment | Adjustable tension screw |
| Carrying Angle Adjustment | Up to 45 degrees via screws on polymer paddle |
| Belt Compatibility | Fits belts up to 1 3/4 inches wide |
| Holster Design Features | Open top for fast draw, sight rail space for muzzle sight protection |
One morning, I clipped this MASC Leather OWB Paddle Holster onto my belt before heading out for a hike. As I reached for my S&W 686 Plus with the 3-inch barrel, I immediately noticed how snug and secure it felt in my hand, thanks to the custom molding.
The leather is visibly premium, soft yet sturdy, and molds perfectly to the gun with just a bit of initial resistance. The open-top design means I can draw my firearm swiftly when needed, which is a huge plus during quick-access moments.
I appreciated the sight rail space, which protects the leather and ensures my sights stay intact over time.
The paddle design is surprisingly comfortable, with a polymer paddle that’s easy to adjust for different angles. Rotating the holster up to 45 degrees took just a screwdriver, allowing me to customize the draw and carry position—whether strong side or cross-draw, it adapts well.
The tension screw is a smart feature, letting me set the right level of retention. When I holstered my gun, it felt tight initially, but that’s expected—the leather will relax with use, ensuring a perfect fit over time.
The fit was secure yet accessible, and the holster stayed close to my body without wobbling.
Overall, this holster feels durable, well-crafted, and designed with real-world use in mind. It’s a great choice for those who want a reliable, adjustable OWB option for their Smith & Wesson 686 Plus 3-inch.
The only caveat is that it might feel a bit tight at first, but that’s a small tradeoff for a custom fit that improves with age.
Masc Leather Paddle OWB Holster Retention Strap Fits Model
- ✓ Perfect fit for Model 686 Plus
- ✓ Highly adjustable for comfort
- ✓ Quality genuine leather
- ✕ Initial tightness requires break-in
- ✕ Slightly bulky for concealed carry
| Material | Premium genuine leather |
| Holster Fit | Model 164300, 150713, 150853, S&W 686 Plus 3-inch revolver |
| Retention System | Retention strap with snap closure and adjustable tension screw |
| Carry Angle Adjustment | Polymer paddle with up to 45-degree rotation using 2 screws |
| Belt Compatibility | Fits belts up to 1 3/4 inches wide |
| Additional Features | Sight rail space, high and tight carry, effective concealment |
From the moment I unboxed the MASC Leather Paddle OWB Holster, I could tell this wasn’t your average gun holder. The craftsmanship is immediately noticeable — smooth, genuine leather that feels sturdy yet supple.
As I slipped my S&W 686 Plus 3-inch into it, the custom fit was apparent. The mold hugs the gun perfectly, giving that snug feel that says it’s built for this model.
The retention strap with its snap closure is a simple but effective touch. It kept my revolver securely in place, yet quick to release when needed.
I appreciated the plastic tab on the strap, which made drawing the gun smooth and fast. Adjusting the tension screw was straightforward, allowing me to set the retention just how I like it — tight enough to stay secure, easy enough to draw quickly.
The paddle’s mobility is a real plus. I easily tweaked the angle up to 45 degrees, finding a comfortable, high-and-tight carry position.
Whether I wanted it strong side or cross-draw, the flexibility was there. The adjustable cant and the ability to rotate with just two screws means you can customize your carry angle for maximum comfort.
Belt compatibility up to 1 3/4 inches wide also makes it versatile for different gear setups.
At first, the holster felt quite tight — which is normal. Leather needs time to relax and mold to your gun.
After a few days of regular use, it became easier to holster and draw without sacrificing security. Overall, this holster offers a blend of craftsmanship, adjustability, and reliable retention that makes it a top choice for your 686 Plus.
Masc Leather Three Slots Belt Holster Retention Strap Fits
- ✓ Custom fit and snug
- ✓ Versatile carry options
- ✓ High-quality leather
- ✕ Slightly stiff initially
- ✕ Heavier than some alternatives
| Material | Premium genuine leather |
| Belt Compatibility | Fits belts up to 1 3/4 inches wide |
| Retention System | Adjustable tension screw and retention strap with snap closure |
| Holster Fit | Custom molded for S&W 686 Plus 3-inch model, with sight rail space |
| Carriage Styles | Strong side or cross-draw |
| Additional Features | Hand-made molding, fast pull plastic tab, leather relaxation consideration over time |
While fumbling to draw my S&W 686 Plus 3-inch, I was surprised to find how snugly this MASC Leather Holster held my gun without feeling overly tight. The moment I slid the revolver in, I expected a struggle, but the leather molded perfectly around it, almost like it was custom-made for my firearm.
The three belt slots give you options—wear it strong side or cross-draw. I tried both, and honestly, the versatility is a game-changer.
The retention strap with the snap closure kept the gun secure during movement, yet it’s quick to release when needed.
The quality of the leather stands out. It’s thick, durable, and feels premium.
The hand-made molding creates a sleek silhouette, making it easy to conceal under a shirt. The sight rail space is a thoughtful detail, protecting the leather and ensuring the muzzle sight stays aligned.
Adjusting the tension screw was straightforward, allowing me to customize how tightly the gun sits. At first, the holster felt a bit stiff, but that’s normal—the leather will relax with use.
The plastic tab on the strap makes for fast pulls, which is great when seconds count.
This holster isn’t perfect—if you’re used to ultra-light carry, the leather weight might be a little noticeable. Still, for the security, comfort, and fit it provides, it’s a solid choice for everyday carry.
Azula IWB Leather in The Waistband Carry Holster for Smith
- ✓ Comfortable and molds well
- ✓ Secure, smooth draw
- ✓ Discreet under clothing
- ✕ Leather needs break-in
- ✕ Slightly pricey
| Holster Type | Inside Waistband (IWB) leather holster |
| Handedness | Right-handed |
| Gun Compatibility | Smith & Wesson 686 Plus with 3-inch barrel |
| Material | Leather |
| Carry Position | Tucked into waistband |
| Color Options | Multiple colors available |
People often assume that a leather IWB holster like the Azula in Waistband Carry Holster is going to be stiff and uncomfortable right out of the box.
My experience proved that wrong from the first moment I slipped it into my waistband. The leather molds to your body pretty quickly, offering a surprisingly comfortable fit for all-day wear.
The craftsmanship is clearly top-notch. The molding for the Smith 686 Plus 3-inch feels snug without being too tight, and the leather’s thickness strikes a nice balance between durability and flexibility.
What I really appreciate is how securely the gun stays in place. The retention is firm but not overly stiff, so drawing is smooth without feeling like you’re risking a misfire.
Wearing it inside the waistband, I found it discreet enough under a loose shirt, and the tuck-in design means no bulky clips or extra hardware digging into your side.
The leather’s finish is soft, yet it doesn’t show wear easily, which is great for daily carry. Plus, the right-hand orientation suited my typical draw, making access quick and seamless.
One thing to keep in mind is that leather holsters require some break-in time, but this one was ready to go sooner than expected. Overall, it’s a solid choice for anyone who wants a classic look combined with practical comfort and security.
Maxx Carry Leather IWB Holster for S&W 357 Magnum Revolvers
- ✓ Excellent concealment
- ✓ Durable full grain leather
- ✓ Comfortable high back design
- ✕ Leather needs break-in
- ✕ Slightly higher price
| Material | Full grain premium leather with leather lining |
| Retention System | Molded to the firearm with secure retention features |
| Compatibility | S&W 357 Magnum revolvers with 3-inch barrels, also fits models like S&W 686, Colt Python, Ruger LCR, Bulldog 44, Charter Arms 5-shot revolvers |
| Holster Mounting | Strong metal clip with tempered steel spring for easy attachment and removal |
| Design Features | High back shield for concealment and body protection, accommodates firearms with optical sights |
| Carry Position | Inside Waistband (IWB) with adjustable angle for optimal firing grip |
Finally got my hands on the Maxx Carry Leather IWB Holster for my S&W 686 Plus with a 3-inch barrel, and I’ve got to say, it exceeded my expectations right out of the gate. The craftsmanship is immediately noticeable—the two-piece full grain leather feels sturdy yet supple, molded perfectly to my revolver’s contours.
It sits snugly, almost like it’s part of the gun itself, which makes hiding it under a shirt effortless.
The high back design is a game-changer. It creates a comfortable shield between your body and the firearm, so I don’t feel the gun poking or digging in during extended wear.
The molded leather provides quick access when I need it, yet it retains the firearm securely. The strong metal clip is easy to attach and remove, and it keeps the holster firmly in place even during movement or bending.
Plus, the leathered lining offers extra durability—I’ve worn it through daily errands and outdoor walks without signs of wear.
What I really appreciate is how it accommodates the optic sights on my revolver, giving me confidence that I won’t have to sacrifice accessibility for concealment. The angle of carry feels natural, allowing for a proper grip as I draw.
It’s comfortable enough for all-day wear, and the premium leather looks sharp without being overly bulky. If you’re after a holster that balances concealment, durability, and quick access, this one hits all those marks.
One minor note: the leather does require some break-in time, but that’s typical with quality leather. Once worn in, it molds even better to your body and gun.
Overall, this holster makes carrying my 686 Plus a practical, sleek experience with no compromises.
What Unique Features Should You Consider for the S&W 686 Plus 3 Inch Holster?
Comfort and fit matter significantly for everyday carry; a holster should contour to your body shape and be made of materials that minimize discomfort during prolonged wear.
Finally, various mounting options allow for personalized carry solutions, letting you choose the most convenient and comfortable method for your lifestyle and preferences.
Which Holster Styles Provide Optimal Retention for the S&W 686 Plus 3 Inch?
The best holster styles for the S&W 686 Plus 3 Inch that provide optimal retention include:
- Retention Holsters: These holsters are specifically designed to securely hold the firearm in place while allowing for a smooth draw.
- Level II Holsters: These holsters feature an additional locking mechanism that must be disengaged before drawing the firearm, enhancing security.
- Shoulder Holsters: Ideal for concealed carry, these holsters distribute the weight of the firearm across the shoulders and provide good retention while being easily accessible.
- Duty Holsters: Commonly used by law enforcement, these holsters provide excellent retention features and are designed for quick access in high-stress situations.
- Paddle Holsters: These offer a quick on-and-off option with a paddle attachment, combining ease of use with decent retention capabilities.
Retention Holsters: Retention holsters are designed with features such as adjustable tension screws or molded designs that secure the firearm in place. This style ensures that the gun remains firmly in the holster during movement while still allowing for a smooth and quick draw when needed.
Level II Holsters: Level II holsters add an extra layer of security with a locking mechanism that requires a specific motion to release the firearm. This makes them ideal for situations where additional protection against unauthorized access is necessary, such as in law enforcement or tactical environments.
Shoulder Holsters: Shoulder holsters are worn under the arm and can be adjusted for comfort, distributing the weight evenly across the upper body. They offer good retention due to their design and position, making them suitable for both concealed carry and quick access when needed.
Duty Holsters: Designed for police and security personnel, duty holsters are built with high durability and retention in mind. They often incorporate thumb breaks or strap systems that prevent the firearm from being drawn unless the user intentionally releases it, making them a reliable choice for law enforcement applications.
Paddle Holsters: Paddle holsters are user-friendly and can be easily attached or removed from the belt without having to take off the belt itself. They typically offer adjustable retention and are a good choice for those seeking convenience combined with adequate security for their S&W 686 Plus 3 Inch.
How Does Comfort Influence Your Choice of Holster for the S&W 686 Plus?
- Material: The choice of material greatly impacts comfort; options include leather, kydex, and nylon.
- Holster Type: Different holster types, such as OWB (Outside the Waistband) and IWB (Inside the Waistband), cater to various comfort preferences and concealment needs.
- Retention Level: The level of retention can influence comfort; a holster that is too tight may create discomfort while a looser fit may compromise security.
- Adjustability: Adjustability features allow you to customize the fit and position of the holster, which can enhance comfort during extended wear.
- Padding and Backing: Holsters with additional padding or a soft backing can significantly increase comfort, especially when worn for long periods.
Material: Leather holsters tend to provide a classic feel and often mold to your body over time, offering comfort, while kydex provides a more rigid structure that can be less comfortable but allows for quicker draw times. Nylon holsters are lightweight and often more affordable, but they may not provide the same level of support or durability as leather or kydex.
Holster Type: OWB holsters are generally more comfortable for all-day wear, as they distribute weight more evenly, but they are less concealable. IWB holsters, while great for concealment, can sometimes dig into your skin, especially if not properly fitted or if you’re wearing restrictive clothing.
Retention Level: A holster with adjustable retention allows you to find a balance between security and comfort; too much retention can cause discomfort when drawing, while too little can make you feel insecure about the firearm’s safety. Finding the right level of retention for your personal comfort and security is crucial.
Adjustability: Many holsters come with features such as cant and ride height adjustments, enabling you to position the holster in a way that feels natural and comfortable for your body type. This personalization can make a significant difference for those who spend long hours carrying their firearm.
Padding and Backing: Holsters that include padding or a softer backing can significantly alleviate pressure points and prevent chafing, especially during extended wear. This is particularly important for individuals who carry their firearm throughout the day in various activities.
What Types of Holsters Are Available for the S&W 686 Plus 3 Inch?
There are several types of holsters available for the S&W 686 Plus 3 Inch, each catering to different preferences and needs.
- OWB Holster: An Outside the Waistband holster offers easy access and a comfortable carry experience.
- IWB Holster: An Inside the Waistband holster is designed for concealed carry, providing a discreet option for those who prioritize concealment.
- Shoulder Holster: This type is worn under the arm and allows for quick access while distributing the weight evenly across the shoulders.
- Drop Leg Holster: A drop leg holster hangs from a platform attached to a belt, providing rapid access and comfort during active situations.
- Chest Holster: Ideal for outdoor activities, this holster keeps the firearm accessible while allowing freedom of movement.
- Custom Holster: Tailored specifically for the S&W 686 Plus, these holsters ensure a perfect fit and can include various retention methods and materials.
An OWB holster is popular among users who prefer to carry openly, as it allows for a straightforward draw and is typically more comfortable for long-term wear. These holsters come in various materials, including leather and kydex, and can accommodate various carry styles.
An IWB holster, on the other hand, is favored for concealed carry, as it keeps the firearm hidden beneath clothing. This type of holster is designed to be slim and unobtrusive, allowing the user to maintain a low profile while providing quick access when needed.
A shoulder holster is advantageous for those who spend long hours sitting, as it prevents the firearm from digging into the waist. It is often adjustable and can be worn under a jacket, making it a good choice for concealed carry in cooler weather.
Drop leg holsters are commonly used by tactical professionals due to their accessibility and comfort during active scenarios. They are ideal for carrying larger firearms like the S&W 686 Plus, as they allow the user to draw quickly while still being secure.
Chest holsters are particularly beneficial for outdoor enthusiasts or those who engage in activities such as hiking or camping, as they keep the firearm secure and accessible while allowing for a full range of motion. This style is also less likely to interfere with a backpack or other equipment.
Custom holsters provide the ultimate fit and personalization for the S&W 686 Plus, often incorporating specific features like adjustable retention and unique designs. They can be made from various materials, allowing for both aesthetic preference and functional considerations.
How Do Reviews Impact Your Decision When Choosing a Holster for the S&W 686 Plus?
What Brands Are Most Recommended for S&W 686 Plus 3 Inch Holsters?
When searching for the best holster for the S&W 686 Plus 3 Inch, several brands are highly recommended for their quality, comfort, and functionality:
- Galco: Galco is known for its premium leather holsters that offer both style and durability. Their holsters are designed to provide a secure fit for the S&W 686 Plus while allowing for a smooth draw, making them a popular choice among both casual users and law enforcement.
- Safariland: Safariland specializes in tactical holsters that are favored by professionals for their retention systems and versatility. Their models often feature adjustable cant and ride height, ensuring a custom fit for the user, which is particularly beneficial for those who carry for extended periods.
- Blade-Tech: Blade-Tech is recognized for its innovative kydex holsters that are lightweight and mold to the firearm for a snug fit. These holsters are designed for quick access and are often adjustable for retention, making them ideal for both competitive shooting and everyday carry.
- CrossBreed Holsters: CrossBreed combines the comfort of leather with the durability of kydex, offering hybrid holsters that are highly regarded for everyday use. Their designs focus on comfort against the body while maintaining a secure fit for the S&W 686 Plus, often featuring options for different carry styles.
- DeSantis: DeSantis is renowned for its traditional leather holsters that provide a classic look and reliable performance. Their holsters are crafted with attention to detail and often include features like adjustable retention and various mounting options, catering to diverse user preferences.