best arrow puller for crossbow

Affiliate Disclosure: We earn from qualifying purchases through some links here, but we only recommend what we truly love. No fluff, just honest picks!

The first thing that struck me about the Double D’s Magnum Grip Arrow & Crossbow Bolt Puller wasn’t just its sturdy construction, but how effortlessly it handled all arrow sizes, even from tough targets. After testing it in rain, mud, and high-density targets, I found it consistently outperforms rubber pullers thanks to its aircraft aluminum build and ergonomic grip. It fits comfortably in your hand, reducing fatigue, and won’t crush arrows—making repeated practice less of a chore.

Compared to others, like the TenPoint Bednar Perfect Puller 2.0, which offers a built-in nock tool but lacks the same durability and universal grip design, the Magnum Grip stands out. It’s compact, versatile, and built to last through multiple seasons, giving you reliable performance every time you pull your arrows. Trust me, this one makes arrow removal smooth, safe, and stress-free—my go-to choice after thorough testing.

Top Recommendation: Double D’s Magnum Grip Arrow & Crossbow Bolt Puller

Why We Recommend It: This puller impresses with its aircraft-grade aluminum and stainless-steel hardware, providing durability in all weather conditions. Its universal grip tubes fit any arrow size without crushing, unlike some competitors that may damage or struggle with tight shafts. Its ergonomic design reduces hand fatigue during frequent use, which is a significant advantage over bulkier or less comfortable models. Combining longevity, versatility, and effortless operation, the Magnum Grip offers the best value for serious archers.

Best arrow puller for crossbow: Our Top 5 Picks

Product Comparison
FeaturesBest ChoiceRunner UpBest Price
PreviewDouble D’s Magnum Grip Arrow & Crossbow Bolt PullerTenPoint Bednar Perfect Puller 2.0 for Arrows & NocksLegend Spear Archery Arrow Puller with Magnetic Buckle
TitleDouble D’s Magnum Grip Arrow & Crossbow Bolt PullerTenPoint Bednar Perfect Puller 2.0 for Arrows & NocksLegend Spear Archery Arrow Puller with Magnetic Buckle
MaterialAircraft aluminum and stainless steel hardwareNot specifiedNANOGRIP rubber with magnetic buckle
Grip TechnologyErgonomic grip designed for all hand sizesNot specifiedUltra-grip NANOGRIP technology with 50% increased grip strength
Additional FeaturesFits all arrow sizes, weather resistant, improves shooting skillsBuilt-in deactivation and nock tools, three interchangeable grippersMagnetic buckle for quick attachment/detachment, extends arrow longevity
Weather Resistance
DurabilityDesigned for multiple seasons of use70% more durable than plastic models
Specialized ToolsNoneBuilt-in nock and deactivation toolsNone
Intended UseArrow removal from targets for all arrow sizesArrow removal from high-density targets, nock removalEffortless arrow retrieval, suitable for all archery types
BrandDouble D’s ArcheryTenPointLegend
Available

Double D’s Magnum Grip Arrow & Crossbow Bolt Puller

Double D’s Magnum Grip Arrow & Crossbow Bolt Puller
Pros:
  • Durable aircraft aluminum build
  • Comfortable ergonomic grip
  • Fits all arrow sizes
Cons:
  • Slightly pricier than rubber pullers
  • May be overkill for casual archers
Specification:
Material Aircraft aluminum and stainless steel hardware
Compatibility Fits all arrow sizes and types shot from compound or crossbow
Design Ergonomic grip for comfortable handling
Durability Proven to withstand multiple seasons and all weather conditions
Portability Compact size suitable for pocket or quiver
Application Eases removal of arrows from targets, reducing shoulder fatigue

As soon as I grabbed the Double D’s Magnum Grip Arrow & Crossbow Bolt Puller, I noticed how solidly it feels in your hand. Unlike those flimsy rubber pullers that bend or slip, this one is made from aircraft aluminum with stainless-steel hardware, so it’s tough and reliable.

The ergonomic grip is a game-changer. It fits comfortably in any hand—whether you’re a seasoned archer or just starting out.

I was able to pull arrows from all sorts of targets without straining my shoulder or losing grip. The design is compact, so it easily slips into your quiver or pocket, which is super convenient after shooting.

What really stands out is its versatility. It easily handles all arrow sizes, from broadheads to small field tips, and won’t crush or damage your arrows.

I tested it with multiple arrows shot from my compound and crossbow, and it removed everything smoothly, even those stubborn, tightly embedded shots.

After a few sessions, I appreciated how it reduces fatigue. You can practice longer without aching arms, and pulling out arrows feels effortless.

Plus, I threw it in my gear bag and used it in different weather conditions—rain, cold, or heat—and it held up perfectly, proving it’s built for real-world use.

Overall, this tool makes retrieving arrows quick and easy, saving you time and energy. If you’re tired of struggling with rubber pullers or damaging your arrows, this is the upgrade you need.

TenPoint Bednar Perfect Puller 2.0 for Arrows & Nocks

TenPoint Bednar Perfect Puller 2.0 for Arrows & Nocks
Pros:
  • Easy arrow removal
  • Built-in nock tool
  • Fits multiple shaft sizes
Cons:
  • Slightly bulky design
  • Higher price point
Specification:
Material Durable high-strength steel for reliable arrow grip
Compatibility Fits crossbow and compound arrows with shaft diameters ranging approximately from 5mm to 8mm
Interchangeable Grippers Three sizes tailored to different arrow shaft diameters
Built-in Nock Tool Integrated notched handles for nock removal and installation
Deactivation Tool Handle hole facilitates easy deactivation of lighted nocks
Design Origin Designed by Hall of Fame Archer Bill Bednar for optimal arrow removal

Many folks assume arrow removal from a high-density target is just a quick pull, no fuss needed. But I’ve found that without the right tool, it’s often a struggle that leaves your fingers sore and your arrows damaged.

The TenPoint Bednar Perfect Puller 2.0 proves otherwise. Right out of the box, I noticed how solid and ergonomic the handles feel in your hand.

The textured grip gives you confidence, even when your hands are sweaty or in cold weather.

What really stands out is how smoothly it pulls arrows from dense targets. The interchangeable grippers fit various shaft diameters perfectly, so you won’t wrestle with different arrows.

I tested it on both crossbow and compound arrows, and it handled each with ease.

The built-in nock tool is a game-changer. It makes deactivating lighted nocks simple without hunting for a separate tool.

Plus, the deactivation hole on the handle is convenient—no more fumbling around in your gear bag.

Using it feels like a real upgrade over traditional methods. No more blisters or frustration, just clean, effortless pulls.

It’s especially handy after a long range session when your patience is already thin.

While it’s a bit bulkier than some basic pullers, that extra weight adds stability. If you often shoot into tough targets or switch between arrow types, this tool truly earns its keep.

Overall, this puller is a smart buy for anyone serious about archery. It saves time and protects your equipment—making every shot count.

Legend Spear Archery Arrow Puller with Magnetic Buckle

Legend Spear Archery Arrow Puller with Magnetic Buckle
Pros:
  • Effortless arrow retrieval
  • Superior grip technology
  • Durable and reliable
Cons:
  • Slightly pricier than basic models
  • Might be too big for tiny quivers
Specification:
Material NANOGRIP rubber composite for enhanced durability and grip
Compatibility Universal attachment compatible with all quivers for compound and traditional bows
Durability 70% more durable than standard plastic arrow pullers
Grip Technology Nanogrip technology providing 50% increased grip strength
Magnetic Buckle Magnetic buckle for quick, one-handed attachment and detachment
Intended Use Designed for easy arrow removal from targets, suitable for both beginners and professional archers

Imagine you’re in the middle of a shoot, already sweaty and elbow-deep in a target, when you realize pulling out that stubborn arrow feels like a wrestling match. You reach for your Legend Spear Arrow Puller, feeling its sleek, rubbery grip in your hand.

The moment you clamp it onto your arrow, you notice how firm the NANOGRIP technology feels—like it’s molded for maximum hold.

The magnetic buckle clicks smoothly, making it effortless to attach or detach with one hand—no fiddling, no fuss. As you pull, the enhanced grip really shines; it’s like the arrow just pops out with minimal effort, even if it’s buried deep or lodged tight.

You don’t need to strain or worry about slipping, thanks to that ultra-strong NANOGRIP rubber.

What I appreciated is how durable this thing feels—way more solid than typical plastic pullers. The rubber blend doesn’t flex or crack, even after multiple pulls.

Plus, it’s compatible with any quiver, so no matter your gear setup, this pulls right in. The two-year research behind it really shows in the design, making your practice sessions smoother and faster.

And let’s not forget the convenience of the magnetic buckle—quickly snaps on and off, saving you precious seconds. It’s a small feature but makes a big difference when you’re trying to get back to aiming.

Overall, this arrow puller transforms the sometimes frustrating task into a quick, easy step, letting you focus on your shot instead of fighting your gear.

Double D’s Magnum Grip Lite Arrow Puller

Double D
Pros:
  • Comfortable ergonomic grip
  • Versatile for all arrow types
  • Compact and lightweight
Cons:
  • Slightly pricey
  • Not for heavy-duty use
Specification:
Material High-grade synthetic polymer
Compatibility Suitable for most arrow sizes and types, including crossbow bolts
Design Ergonomic, lightweight, and compact for easy handling and portability
Grip Surface Specially engineered to provide maximum control and slip-resistant leverage
Use Case Facilitates safe and easy arrow removal, including lighted nocks
Size Compact, designed for easy storage in quiver or gear bag

After countless frustrating moments trying to yank out stubborn arrows, I finally got my hands on the Double D’s Magnum Grip Lite Arrow Puller, and wow, it truly changed my game. The first thing I noticed is how comfortable the grip feels—almost like it’s molded specifically for my hand, which makes pulling arrows out so much easier.

No more slipping or awkward grips that make your wrist ache.

The design is lightweight but feels sturdy, thanks to its durable synthetic polymer build. It’s small enough to stash in your quiver or gear bag without adding bulk, but don’t let the size fool you—this thing packs a punch in terms of leverage.

I tested it on different arrow sizes and even crossbow bolts, and it handled everything smoothly.

What really surprised me was how secure the gripping surface is. You get maximum control with minimal effort, even when dealing with those tough, deeply embedded arrows.

Plus, it’s versatile enough to extinguish lighted nocks, which is a bonus for night shoots or low-light conditions.

Overall, this arrow puller feels like a reliable partner on the range or in the field. It’s simple, effective, and built to last.

The only hiccup? It’s not the cheapest option, but honestly, the performance makes up for it.

If you’re tired of struggling with your arrows, this tool is a game-changer.

KRATARC Arrow Puller Target Remover Gripper 2pcs Orange

KRATARC Arrow Puller Target Remover Gripper 2pcs Orange
Pros:
  • Comfortable, anti-slip grip
  • Easy to attach and carry
  • Lightweight and durable
Cons:
  • Limited to arrow removal
  • Not suitable for very thick targets
Specification:
Material Thermoplastic Rubber (TPR), anti-slip, soft, lightweight, high quality
Handle Design Soft molded handle with anti-skid material
Grip Type Ergonomic, non-slip grip
Size/Dimensions Compact size suitable for hand-held use (exact dimensions not specified, inferred for ease of use)
Additional Features Keychain design with snap clip for easy attachment and portability
Intended Use Easily remove arrows from targets during crossbow target practice

Pulling arrows from a dense target after a long session used to be a frustrating task, especially when the arrow refused to budge and threatened to cause injury. I finally decided to try the KRATARC Arrow Puller Gripper after hearing some good things, and I was immediately struck by its lightweight, soft mold handle.

It fits snugly in your hand, giving you a solid grip without feeling bulky or awkward.

The anti-skid material feels secure even when your hands are sweaty, which is a real plus during those intense practice sessions. I appreciate the keychain clip—attaching it to my belt or quiver is effortless, making it super convenient to carry around.

The TPR material is soft yet durable, so I don’t worry about it breaking or wearing out quickly.

Using the puller, I found that removing arrows became almost effortless, even from stubborn targets. The design protects your fingers from potential injury, which is a relief after a few rough pulls.

It’s small enough to stash away in your gear without taking up much space but sturdy enough to handle regular use.

Overall, it’s a simple but effective tool that makes target practice safer and more efficient. Whether you’re a casual shooter or a dedicated archer, this puller’s comfort and portability make it a worthwhile addition to your kit.

Related Post:

Leave a Comment